![]() Harrington believes that the verse is based on an ancient proverb whose exact meaning is not known. By this interpretation the left hand not knowing what the right is doing is a metaphor for how covert the proper donor should be. Lewis takes a third approach, arguing the proverb is a metaphor for secrecy, and that it was earlier used as such by the Stoics. Fowler agrees with this second interpretation, and believes that Matthew 6:4 bears it out. This view sees this verse simply of a metaphor explaining the rules already laid out in the previous two verse. ![]() Thus the verse means that right hand should by reflex be generous without the need for mental calculus, and if the mind is avoided so too is the left hand. If one spends too much effort pondering giving, one will scheme to have even secret donations made public so that you might be praised. Giving should be an automatic action without need to consider the potential rewards. An alternate view, expressed by Filson, is that this verse is not a condemnation of smugness, but rather of scheming for public praise. Hendriksen feels this view is supported by Matthew 25:37- 39. One should not feel smug about our own goodness, but should rather try to forget our own good deeds. One interpretation, outlined by Hendriksen, is that Jesus is here stating that just as we should avoid seeking the praise of others for our good deeds, we should also avoid self-congratulation for our piety. Since the owner of the hands must know what both are doing, Jesus' statement here is thus generally considered a humorous hyperbole. This is quite different from this verse where Jesus presents the lack of coordination as an ideal. However "the left hand doesn't know what the right hand is doing" is generally a term of derision for an organization where different members are pursuing opposing or contradictory goals. This verse is the origin of a common English expression. This verse uses a metaphor to build on this argument, but there is some debate over exactly what this metaphor means. The previous two verses argued that charitable giving should be kept secret, so that it is not done for praise by others. Your left hand know what your right hand does, But when you do merciful deeds, don’t let
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |